analyzing the car confession of Joran van der Sloot
4 februari 2008 18:17:
Was Natalee Holloway dumped into the ocean by ‘a friend’ of Joran van der Sloot...? The alarming confession Peter R. de Vries managed to tape, leaves us with many questions and possibilities... The confession seems to consist of five assertions 1) Natalee just collapsed 2) Joran did not call an ambulance 3) Joran went to a pay phone to call for 'help' id est: help to dump Natalee, alive or dead 4) A Friend came with his boat and dumped Natalee -either in coma or dead- into the ocean 5) Joran dumped his shoes into the sewer. These claims, assertions, confessions, whatever you prefer, lead to at least thirty questions....:
| (Alleged) Confession and or Fact: | Reason(s) to be True or Untrue: | Questions remaining: | Possible crime: |
| “Natalee just collapsed..” | Can be TRUE: alcohol, drugs | But if true: why did Joran not call an ...ambulance? He carried a cellphone. | Denying help to a person in an alarming situation |
| “Natalee just collapsed..” | Can be UNTRUE: Joran may have done something, that made Natalee collapse | If untrue: was it Jorans intention to harm Natalee, or did his action unintentionally make her pass out? What did this 'i wanted her to suck cock'-line mean in relation to this? | Possible crime: (intentional) harm to Natalee |
| Joran did not call an ambulance | —this is a FACT— | Why did Joran not want a Medic to examine Natalee? | Possible crime: covering up harmfull behaviour |
| “Joran went to a pay phone to call for ‘help’ (id est: help to dump Natalee)” | This has to be investigated: If TRUE: | Why did Joran not use his ...cell phone? Did he know he was doing something illegal, and thought the pay phone could not be traced? | Intention to commit a crime, and leaving someone in need of help alone in the bushes |
| “Joran went to a pay phone to call for ‘help’” | This has to be investigated: If TRUE, id est: if Joran did make a call: | Who did he speak to and what did he ask? Did Joran really ask a Friend to ....come over to the beach in the ...middle of the night? To ...dump a dead body? Or did he just ask if he could borrow someones boat? | Intention to commit a crime, involving someone-else in an crime, leaving someone in need of help alone in the bushes |
| “Joran went to a pay phone to call for ‘help’” | If UNTRUE, if it would be proven there is no record of a call, that night: | Did Joran just made it up, because he knew his cell-phone-records had been investigated allready, and only mentioning a pay phone would make his ‘confession’ believable? | Possible crime: trying to cover up the fact that he disposed Natalee's body all by himself |
| “A Friend came with his boat and dumped Natalee —either in coma or dead— into the ocean” | If TRUE | Who would do such a thing for a friend and Why? Can this friend be traced and questioned, could this story be confirmed? | Possible crime: collaboration in hiding a body and possible, hiding a crime; Possible: murder if Natalee was still alive |
| “A Friend came with his boat and dumped Natalee —either in coma or dead— into the ocean” | If UNTRUE | The way Joran tells this story, his mimic, tone of voice, eyemovements, gives me the feeling that part of this story could be a lie. Was it really a friend? Someone-else? Would the second person really have checked to see if Natalee was dead just by bending over her, like Joran says? Would a second person risk murder for Joran? Or ...did Joran not ask for help at all, did he just use someones boat? | Possible crime: hiding a body; Possible: murder if Natalee was still alive |
| “A Friend came with his boat and dumped Natalee —either in coma or dead— into the ocean” | If UNTRUE | The confessions about Natalee's body and collapse ("The ocean is big..." — "I am so lucky she is not been found" — "She's never going to be found" — "I am in trouble if she is found" — "As soon as there has been a courtcase and I am acquitted, it is not even a problem anymore if she's found with my sperm in her body" — "No, no foam on her lips, she just stopped") sounded believable to me. I believe that Joran has indeed watched Natalee collapse and maybe even die. But if Joran's Friend+boat-story sounds less sincere, and would be a lie, where is Natalees body? In an early part of the car-confession: Joran answers "Yes" to the question ± "..haar de zee in gedaan? Alleen?" (± Did you put her in the sea? Alone?) Although such a question is suggestive, I would not rule out the possibility that Joran took a boat all by himself, to dump Natalee | Possible crime: hiding a body; Possible: murder if Natalee was still alive and left on the beach or dumped into the water |
| “Joran dumped his shoes into the sewer” | This has to be investigated: If TRUE: | Why did he get rid of the shoes? Did they contain evidence of something? Did they leave certain marks on a boat? Did they contain evidence that could trace him back to a certain boat or any other place on the island? | Hiding evidence, whatever reason he had to get rid of the shoes, that fact makes him look suspicious |
[ reacties ]
©